Anglers Key
For those seeking ultimate privacy and generous living space right on the beach, Anglers Key is a hidden gem. Located on the west end of the island on prestigious West Gulf Drive, this exclusive beachfront enclave features only 6 luxury residences—each offering expansive Gulf views and the tranquility of a low-density community.
Anglers Key combines the serenity of a residential-style setting with the beauty of Sanibel’s pristine shoreline. Ideal for owners who value peace, space, and limited rental activity, this community offers a refined island lifestyle in one of Sanibel’s most sought-after mid-island locations.
- Ultra-Private Community: Just 6 units for unmatched privacy and exclusivity
- Beachfront Location: Direct access to the Gulf of Mexico with breathtaking views
- Expansive Floor Plans: Three-bedroom residences up to 3,000 sq. ft.
- Built in 1989: Timeless architecture with spacious, well-designed interiors
- Pet-Friendly: Pets allowed for owners; confirm current association policies
- Elevators: for your convenience
- Heated Swimming Pool: A peaceful space to relax and enjoy the Florida sunshine
- Tennis Courts: Onsite for a casual match or some friendly competition
- Covered Parking: under the building for protection from the weather
- Limited Rentals: Monthly Rentals—ensures a quiet, residential atmosphere
Anglers Key offers the rare combination of beachfront luxury, unmatched privacy, and quiet living. With only a few neighbors, no short-term rental traffic, and one of the largest floor plans available on the island, this is the perfect spot to enjoy the understated elegance of Sanibel Island living.
Filters Reset
Save Snapshot
View Results
MARKET SNAPSHOT
- ?Sold Listings
- ?Average Sales Price
- ?Average Days on Market
Market Trends
(Jun 2025 - May 2026)
Please input a valid location in the search bar to view the local market trends.
RECENT LISTINGS
Please input a valid location in the search bar to view recent listings.
GET MORE INFORMATION
Kelly Huguenin
Agent | License ID: SL3370164